What Can Be Substituted For Cream Of Mushroom Soup?

Cream of mushroom soup is a common larder staple used in various dishes to impart a creamy and savory flavor. However, there are situations in which you may require a substitute for cream of mushroom soup, either due to dietary restrictions or the ingredient’s unavailability.

Fortunately, several substitutes can be used interchangeably in various recipes. This article will discuss what can be substituted for cream of mushroom soup.

What Can Be Substituted For Cream Of Mushroom Soup?

Here are the substituted for cream of mushroom soup

1. Chicken Cream Soup

Cream of chicken soup is arguably the most popular alternative to cream of mushroom soup, particularly when creating a creamy sauce or casserole.

First, the consistency is comparable to mushroom cream.

However, this substitute is not vegan-friendly, as it contains chicken instead of mushrooms. In addition, the flavor is less robust than that of cream of mushroom soup.

2. Golden Mushroom Soup

If flavor is the most important factor, consider substituting it with golden mushroom broth. It is widely available and tastes identical to cream of mushroom soup.

However, bear in mind that the consistency of golden mushroom soup is not thick. Therefore, it is not the greatest substitute for creamy soup.

However, golden mushroom soup prepared from scratch is also relatively simple. Fresh mushrooms, garlic, onion, and herbs need only be sautéed over medium heat.

3. Celery-cream Soup

Cream of celery soup is another excellent replacement for cream of mushroom soup clean up-wise. Additionally, it has the desired creaminess of a creamy mushroom broth.

However, celery has a flavor that is quite distinct. It lacks the piquant flavor found in mushrooms. Instead, it has a more herbal flavor, which you may not mind if you enjoy celery.

However, it is the ideal base for velvety soups and broths because its flavor complements rather than overpowers the other ingredients.

If you are not looking for a heavy broth, this is an excellent substitute due to its lighter flavor and vegetable flavor.

4. Heavy Cream

Consider using heavy cream if you primarily use cream of mushroom soup as an ingredient and simply desire its consistency and texture.

Its flavor is not as robust and aromatic, but it helps to thicken soups and sauces. In addition, it has a neutral flavor, so it will not alter the overall flavor profile of your dish.

However, you must still season it with garlic powder, onion powder, herbs, and various seasonings.

5. Potato Cream Soup

Cream of potato soup imparts a savory, bacon-like flavor to your dish, making it an excellent substitute for mushrooms’ meaty flavor.

In addition, some potatoes are inherently high in starch, so the resulting sauce would be denser and thicker than cream of mushroom.

Herbs, garlic, and onion can be added to a cream of potato soup recipe to enhance its flavor.

Similar to other creamy soups on this list, cream of potato soup can be used as a 1:1 substitute.

6. Milk And Cream Cheese

Cream of mushroom soup has the ideal balance of salinity and richness. This is what makes milk and cream cheese suitable alternatives.

The finest aspect is how simple it is to prepare. This recipe should only take a few minutes to prepare.

The ingredients include sautéed mushrooms, garlic, butter, flour, chicken bouillon, and milk. Once the mixture has thickened, cream cheese will be added as the secret ingredient.

7. Sour Cream

This one may sound odd, so you may need to attempt it to understand what we’re talking about. Yes, you can substitute sour cream for cream of mushroom soup.

Sour cream’s flavor profile is not far from a velvety mushroom. However, you must mask its acidic flavor to not overpower your dish.

Milk, mushrooms, and your preferred seasoning must be added to accomplish this. Although it lacks the umami flavor of mushroom soup, it is very convenient to learn this ingredient.

8. Dry Cream Soup Mix

A dry cream soup mix is a soup blend available in grocery stores nationwide. It is a powdered combination of numerous herbs and spices.

You only need to add boiling water to prepare this dish like instant noodles. You may also add milk and other ingredients to achieve a mushroom soup-like flavor.

In addition to being readily available, a dry cream soup blend is an excellent substitute for cream of mushroom soup because it can be prepared in mere minutes.

9. Broccoli-Cream Soup

If you’re a huge fan of vegetables, you shouldn’t lose out on the creamy deliciousness of cream of broccoli soup.

In addition to being healthy, cream of broccoli soup is so delectable that it pairs well with seafood dishes such as tuna casserole and scallops.

This substitute is very simple to locate, which is one of the features I appreciate the most. Numerous firms offer this product in powdered form.

10. Coconut Milk Broth

To all my vegan readers, I want you to know that you do not have to forego the delicious creamy mushroom broth because it contains milk.

Coconut milk can always supplant canned cream or cow’s milk. This is a dairy-free substitute, so lactose-intolerant individuals will also appreciate it.

However, be careful to use unsweetened coconut milk. Otherwise, you may wind up with a sweet mushroom cream soup.

In a casserole, combine coconut milk and bouillon. Change the proportions to achieve the intended consistency. Too skinny? Add coconut milk to the mix. Too dense? Add stock.

Whether you are lactose intolerant, following a specific diet, or simply want to experiment with new flavors, many alternatives to cream of mushroom soup can maintain the richness and creaminess of your dishes. By selecting the appropriate substitute based on your needs and the recipe, you can continue to experience a variety of culinary creations without sacrificing flavor or texture.

Read More: Easy Things To Add To Mac And Cheese

Leave a Comment